Sherwin Williams SuperPaint Exterior Review

SuperPaint used to paint vinyl siding.

A Pro’s Take on SuperPaint and When To Upgrade

Sherwin-Williams Super Paint Exterior is perfect for lowering material costs. There is no better option for those looking for a price-point product from a major brand. It is also really good to use when updating old vinyl siding. Its ‘VinylSafe’ technology is a budget hero for the beautiful 1990s vinyl siding neighborhoods in Landover and Forestville Farms.

It is also used in commercial new construction applications. Whenever a new large building goes up, we often see 200 to 500 gallons stacked at the Sherwin-Williams on Hillboro Street in Raleigh, NC, ready for delivery. For a builder that needs to cover a large area, every dollar saved adds up. But homeowners must watch out. If a contractor senses your inclination toward lower prices, they will often reduce the material quality first. Painters looking to reduce expenses will recommend it and tell you it’s fine to use everywhere. Not always the case.

This staple has been around for a long time. In many ways, it is Sherwin-Williams’ most highly branded exterior paint. While its name is familiar and sales are strong, it is not the best choice for quality exterior repaints.

The Decline in Performance

SuperPaint has been reformulated numerous times over the past few years. As a longtime paint contractor, I have found these changes not to be beneficial. Due to a watery consistency, lack of coverage, and severe overspray, we stopped using SuperPaint as a primary material many years ago.

After several reformulations, the performance started to suffer. When SW launched new solutions, SuperPaint’s performance dropped too low for our high-quality repaints. It claims to contain around 43% solids. However, with gloss finishes, the consistency is too watery to brush. The reformulation clearly reduced pigment, most noticeable in off-white shades in an extra-white base containing little to no added colorant.

Project Factor SuperPaint (Value) Latitude/Duration (Authority)
Substrate Suitability Vinyl Siding, Brick, Stucco Masonite, Wood Siding, Fine-Finish Trim
NC Climate Resistance Moderate; prone to mildew after 3 years Superior; high zinc-oxide levels for Raleigh humidity
Sheen Retention Dulls rapidly in NC UV Index Retains gloss and color integrity for 8+ years
Raleigh Best Use Commercial/New Construction Residential Repaints in North Raleigh/Cary

*Pro Tip: Because labor accounts for ~70% of your quote, upgrading to a premium resin adds less than 5% to the total bill but doubles the lifespan of the finish.

Coverage

SuperPaint does not cover well in light colors. If you are applying it to trim or in a bright color, be prepared to spray to ensure proper coverage. Even then, once it dries, the undercoat will likely still show through. Or be prepared to brush three very thick coats for proper hide.

Brush Work

The best use for this product is low-cost, production-style painting. Detailed brushwork is not its strong suit. The thin consistency is easy to brush but hard to control. Spatters and spills are common when brushing SuperPaint.

Spraying

Spraying is the best way to apply this product. However, it has tremendous overspray due to it being thin. So, you save money on the price but use more and lose more paint due to overspray.

Finish & Sheen

All finishes are available. This includes flat, satin, gloss, and high gloss. Flashing is an issue in satin finishes. Therefore, we recommend applying two generous coats of paint for a uniform shine.

Colors

There are no limits to colors. It is tintable in extra white, deep, and ultra-deep bases. All light and dark colors are available to choose from.

Prepackaged Black

Stock tricorn black is available prepackaged. It covers and retains its color the best. It is our go-to color for shutters and front doors because the iron oxide (Pigment Black 11, (Fe_{3}O_{4}) and carbon black covers better than any black mixed at the store.

Brushing-Sherwin-Williams-SuperPaint

Durability Cost & Upgrades

SuperPaint will only last 4 to 6 years on a properly prepared exterior surface. Its durability isn’t as strong as that of comparable outdoor paints, like Benjamin Moore Element. But if Sherwin-Williams is your preferred brand, upgrade to Latitude for greater protection. It’s a justifiable upgrade.

SuperPaint will save upfront costs and is not the worst performer on the market when compared to DuraCraft and A100. But, like other lower-performing paints, it will increase home maintenance costs over time. If you are selling or renting, this may not be a concern. But there is no debate. Upgrading your paint is a must if you want to control future maintenance costs.

Rising paint costs are forcing homeowners and contractors to make tough decisions. And prices are expected to keep rising. In fact, our prices have not decreased significantly in over 10 years. Since SuperPaint has been around for so long, its price has increased by 400% over the past 25 years.

For many years, it was Sherwin-Williams’s highest-grade exterior paint. But like many products, the changes introduced planned obsolescence, driving our quest for better performance. The first significant change was a price increase. The contractor price in the early 2000s was around $16.00 per gallon. Today, expect to pay between $30 and $45.00 per gallon.

Additional Performance & Surface Applications

This outdoor product is a medium-grade siding paint. However, simply put, your trim, doors, and windows need better protection. Additionally, it leaves a sticky finish after it dries. So, using it for doors and windows is less than ideal.

Applications on brick, stucco, and other concrete surfaces can be brilliant. These surfaces don’t always require heavy protection. However, it should not be applied to wood surfaces that require added protection. Hardboard and Masonite siding need a paint upgrade.

Adhesion and Stain Resistance

The best thing about SuperPaint is how well it sticks to different surfaces. It can stick to thin vinyl and PVC without damage or warping. However, unpainted wood surfaces still need a proper primer.

The not-so-good news is that its stain resistance is poor. Bright white colors show dirt and rainwater stains the worst. Gutters also stain easily from roof water runoff. So, premature black streaks and dirt stains are part of what it means to use SuperPaint.

Expansion and Contraction

For the first 3 to 5 years, it excels in elasticity due to its high vinyl polymer content. Being able to expand and contract helps with expansion joints in siding and trim. In many ways, it stretches almost as well as caulk. But don’t get too excited, because after 5 years, the paint will begin to crack around the expansion joints.

Sheen Retention Loss

Using a satin or glossy finish outdoors adds protection to your home. But a shiny SuperPaint finish exposed to the sun will start to dull faster than higher-quality options and will degrade much faster. Rapid sheen loss makes future touch-ups impossible to blend and match.

Acrylic latex paint is composed of pigments (color) and a binder (the resin/glue). The binder is responsible for the “sheen”. It creates a smooth, continuous film that allows for Specular Reflection (light bouncing off a surface in a single direction, like a mirror).

When paint is exposed to Ultraviolet (UV) radiation, the high-energy photons break the chemical bonds within the polymer chains of the binder. This process, called scission, creates free radicals that react with atmospheric oxygen. This chemical reaction essentially “burns” away the top layer of the resin.

After 3 years, touch-ups simply will not match. So, if the outside has to be redone for any reason, the entire area must be completely repainted.

Mold and Mildew Resistance

Organic growth is prone to accumulating faster. This is because it is a softer coating that primarily consists of vinyl polymers. Higher-grade acrylic and zinc oxide are added to better withstand our wet, humid climate.

All exterior house paints contain at least a low level of zinc oxide. The issue is that the additive is only a protective agent and does not prevent mold, mildew, or algae. Unfortunately, SuperPaint will retain moisture well after zinc oxide has degraded.

Do We Recommend It?

We are a local painting contractor here in Raleigh, NC. We have painted houses year after year for the past two decades. So, we have a lot of firsthand experience. Needless to say, we also have our opinions based on countless real-world applications. Here is the fact. We only use SuperPaint for new construction and commercial exterior painting. We don’t use it or recommend it for residential repaints unless we are painting vinyl. It is the more vinyl-safe SW offering. Otherwise, simply put, it’s no longer a premium product.

If your local company mentions it or wants to use it for your home, ask to upgrade. It sets the standard that you want and expect better quality. 60 to 80% of any painting service is labor. Paying for less durable paint is a true disservice. We will go so far as to say that the painter recommending it should also be questioned.

You are reading this article for information. These are not claims but realities based on our experience. If you live in Raleigh or nearby, contact us. We offer expert service and advice, backed by extensive experience with other products and applications. We back all our services with a warranty, but only when we apply premium paints.

Raleigh painting contractor and home improvement specialist Courtney Ray in company uniform with professional service vehicle.
Courtney Ray (Founder)
A Touch of Color Painting & General Contracting

As a licensed contractor and painter in Raleigh, NC, I am passionate about educating clients and sharing our expertise, experience, and professional recommendations. I have been in business for 22 years, and I look forward to continuing to promote quality materials and services.

Similar Posts