Guiding Local Homeowners to the Best Outdoor Painting Applications
If you are considering the best approach to painting surfaces on the exterior of your Raleigh home, hiring a knowledgeable, honest contractor with the right process, recommendations, flexibility, and skill set for your specific project is critical. One of the most important considerations is determining whether to spray or brush your home.
Some companies prefer hand-painting, while others believe spraying provides better coverage. Is your local painter trying to sell you something you don’t need to make more money? Often, smaller companies or those seeking to distinguish their service will suggest a different approach or step in a way that no one else has. And be aware, once they have your attention, they can often sell you the extra cost of hand-brushing an entire home. When, in actuality, you didn’t even need to.
80% of homes in North Raleigh, NC, are sprayed. In downtown Raleigh, many older homes feature original wood siding with layers of failing old paint. Surfaces containing multiple failing paint layers are often too rough and delicate to spray. For these areas, the paint will need to be spread (brushed) to provide a good seal.
Areas That Benefit From Spraying
Larger areas outside a home can be either sprayed or hand-brushed. The major and most costly consideration is the siding. Jame Hardie lap siding is common on newer Raleigh homes, and there is no advantage to paying extra to brush it. In fact, spraying HardiePlank creates the smooth finish that many North Raleigh HOAs require. Other surfaces, such as gutters, downspouts, porch ceilings, and exterior shutters, can also be sprayed. The one surface that is rarely debated is brick. Painting and whitewashing a large square footage of outdoor brick always involves spraying.
Pediments, garage doors soffit
Masonite Siding & Cracks Sealed By Brushing
For older homes in Raleigh with severely delaminated Masonite lap siding, we often recommend a hand-brushed paint job or full siding replacement. The main advantage of hand-brushing siding is that it forces paint into hairline cracks along surfaces and siding edges where caulking isn’t used. If you don’t have this issue, you don’t need to brush it. However, this seals the edges of siding, often where the delamination is most common on older or neglected homes.
Failing to seal the edge of each board, where Masonite is prone to failure and moisture absorption, will lead to swelling and unwanted expansion due to water intrusion. This exposure leads to water damage because it lacks protection from Raleigh’s frequent summer evening storms and high humidity.
If you want to preserve what you have and budget is a consideration, a hand-brushed paint job is extremely advantageous and cost-effective long-term by protecting the siding until you have budgeted for the inevitable replacement.
Comparing Brushing vs. Spraying Costs & Surfaces
Spraying large surfaces requires roughly 1/3 less labor than brushing. This is because we can complete exterior gables and walls much faster. For example, when we spray home exteriors, a spray man and a ladder man working together often complete one coat on the siding in one day. The same goes for the fascia and soffits, one day! Conversely, hand-brushing two coats on siding takes multiple days and often requires 3 painters or more.
Because of the intricate detail of trim work, doors, windows, transoms, sidelights, and other ornate trim, they are typically hand-brushed. Brushing siding, on the other hand, is labor-intensive. Hand-brushing siding typically requires more than 2 coats of paint for full coverage. Combining spraying and back-brushing or rolling is an advantageous middle ground that can help reduce costs.
Although there are marginal labor and time considerations when spraying, too. Spraying house paint takes more time to cover areas. Setting up and cleaning sprayers is also a consideration, especially when spraying over the course of multiple days. It also requires more material due to paint loss from overspray (unused paint going into the air). However, even when you factor in all the extra steps, spraying is still significantly cheaper. This is a huge testament to how labor-intensive handbrushing is. Which is why you only want to pay for it when it is actually needed.
The false pretense of brushing automatically lasting longer is simply not true. Remember, legitimate claims and recommendations related to home improvement applications should always be viewed circumstantially. This is exactly what is needed for a proper diagnosis on this subject.
Cost When Changing Color and Finish Quality
With the lack of paint coverage prominent in today’s house paints, spraying can help solve that problem. If surfaces are dull, discolored, chalky, or stained, this can add to the challenges of achieving good paint coverage. Spraying two coats will cover almost any surface. Gutters on homes often have black stains from roof runoff or UV oxidation. Often, two brushed coats will not provide adequate coverage. Additionally, part of the excitement of painting is a color change.
We apply two coats in most cases for added protection. So, we always encourage clients to take advantage of changing the color of the siding, shutters, or doors. Typically, spraying paint requires two light coats for repaints and two heavier coats for color changes. So, the added cost of a color change when spraying is only a little extra paint. Compared to handbrushing, which adds the labor of a potential third coat. Honestly, in that situation, both the painters and the client are not happy under those unforeseen circumstances.
The glass-like and car-like finish of spraying is real. Spraying provides a smooth finish free of brush strokes and roller marks. Spraying those black shutters and gutters is the closest you will ever get to the look of a factory-like finish. Additionally, its versatility is unmatched. It can be used on a wide range of surfaces, providing an even finish with minimal to no paint stippling (texture).
Comparing Space, Time & Project Size
When we determine whether to spray or brush, there are other factors to consider. If your project is small, it may be easier to brush it out real quick. Because of its efficiency, spraying may be a better option if the project takes several coats of paint or has a limited window.
Lastly, consider the type of paint and how spraying or brushing will affect its appearance. Brushing leaves marks, which are exacerbated on satin finishes. Spraying leaves a smoother finish on surfaces like flat garage doors or modern front doors. So, smoother surfaces will benefit from a sprayed finish.
The Combination of Spraying & Back-Brushing
While the choice is often framed as one or the other, the most effective way to paint a Raleigh home—especially one with Masonite or delaminating lap siding—is a hybrid technique called back-brushing.
In this process, the paint is first applied with a paint sprayer for speed and volume. A second painter follows immediately behind with a brush to “work” the wet paint into the surface. This offers the best of both worlds.
- Optimal Seal: It seals surfaces that need brushing at 1/2 the cost.
- Labor Efficiency: Brushing a home from a bucket takes 2 to 3 times longer than spraying. Back-brushing allows us to move significantly faster, potentially lowering the labor cost of a “hand-painted” project by thousands of dollars.
If you are discussing these techniques with a local painter, ensure they have specific experience with back-brushing. Because Raleigh can be hot and humid, the “open time” of the paint (the time before it starts to dry) is very short. Back-brushing must be done within seconds of the spray application. If a painter tries to back-brush paint that has already started to “flash” or dry, the result can be disastrous. It will lead to a textured, uneven mess that is very difficult to fix.
Indoor Tricks When Spraying is Not Ideal
The debate between spraying and brushing also extends inside the home. As more Raleigh homeowners request low- or zero-VOC paints, a new challenge has emerged. These eco-friendly paints dry much faster than traditional formulas. If you aren’t careful, this results in heavy, obtrusive brush marks on doors and bookshelves.
When spraying interior trim is too invasive for the homeowner, we use a specific trade secret. Apply the paint quickly with a foam roller or add a paint extender. Combining the two levels out the paint and offers a smooth, uniform finish that mimics a sprayed look without the mess. Also, after using the roller, we can back-brush it immediately if needed.
Thinking of Painting Your Home?
Do you still have questions about spraying vs. brushing? We provide professional exterior paint coatings and aim to make our customers feel as comfortable as possible throughout each project.
We provide services to Raleigh, NC, Cary, and the greater Triangle area.

As a licensed contractor and painter in Raleigh, NC, I am passionate about educating clients and sharing our expertise, experience, and professional recommendations. I have been in business for 22 years, and I look forward to continuing to promote quality materials and services.

